﻿1
00:00:11,712 --> 00:00:14,603
On October 15,
in the midst of the elections,

2
00:00:14,703 --> 00:00:17,568
Camilo Santana, the Workers' Party (PT)
leader in the Senate,

3
00:00:17,668 --> 00:00:20,853
proposed an amendment to the Security
Constitutional Amendment Proposal.

4
00:00:20,953 --> 00:00:24,267
The amendment proposed lowering the
age of criminal liability

5
00:00:24,367 --> 00:00:27,755
to 16 in cases of heinous crimes,

6
00:00:27,855 --> 00:00:31,840
in contrast to the unrestricted
reduction to 14

7
00:00:31,940 --> 00:00:35,232
proposed by Senator Rogério Marinho of
the far right Liberal Party (PL).

8
00:00:35,712 --> 00:00:39,189
Shortly thereafter, during an interview
on mainstream media,

9
00:00:39,289 --> 00:00:42,963
Lula stated that he was in favor of
lowering the age of criminal liability.

10
00:00:43,063 --> 00:00:44,765
- For heinous crimes... - For heinous crimes!

11
00:00:44,765 --> 00:00:46,344
...you support lowering the
age of criminal liability?

12
00:00:46,344 --> 00:00:47,251
- Yes.

13
00:00:47,351 --> 00:00:50,931
  Despite the divisions
surrounding the issue,

14
00:00:51,031 --> 00:00:53,053
the progressive left’s relationship

15
00:00:53,153 --> 00:00:55,528
with penal populism is not new.

16
00:00:55,955 --> 00:00:57,683
Over the last decades,

17
00:00:57,783 --> 00:00:59,923
progressive governments

18
00:01:00,023 --> 00:01:03,475
have collaborated for the expansion
of the penal state

19
00:01:03,575 --> 00:01:04,979
in many parts of the world.

20
00:01:05,597 --> 00:01:06,589
In Brazil,

21
00:01:06,689 --> 00:01:11,165
the 2006 Drug Law and the so-called Public
Security Action Plan (PAC)

22
00:01:11,265 --> 00:01:14,525
were responsible for increasing
mass incarceration

23
00:01:14,625 --> 00:01:20,349
of poor young Black and Indigenous people,
women, and LGBT+ people.

24
00:01:20,819 --> 00:01:24,584
PT’s federal governments
were thus marked

25
00:01:24,684 --> 00:01:27,187
by a “punitive developmentism.”

26
00:01:27,933 --> 00:01:29,725
However, it is a fact

27
00:01:29,825 --> 00:01:33,171
that PT had always openly opposed

28
00:01:33,271 --> 00:01:35,837
the proposal to lower the age
of criminal liability.

29
00:01:36,307 --> 00:01:37,661
This means

30
00:01:37,761 --> 00:01:41,181
that the recent positions adopted
by Camilo Santana and Lula

31
00:01:41,281 --> 00:01:44,221
cross a line that had not
been crossed until now,

32
00:01:44,321 --> 00:01:47,517
raising red flags for
social movements

33
00:01:47,617 --> 00:01:52,147
about the real possibility that the age of
criminal liability could be lowered.

34
00:01:52,637 --> 00:01:54,259
This shift in position

35
00:01:54,359 --> 00:01:57,843
confirms a broader trend within
the progressive sphere

36
00:01:57,943 --> 00:01:59,304
to increasingly yield

37
00:01:59,404 --> 00:02:02,803
to pressure from the far right
regarding public safety.

38
00:02:03,133 --> 00:02:04,989
During Lula’s third administration,

39
00:02:05,089 --> 00:02:07,848
there was an even greater reliance
on penal populism,

40
00:02:07,948 --> 00:02:10,152
leading to an increase in
mass incarceration,

41
00:02:10,252 --> 00:02:11,763
social militarization,

42
00:02:11,863 --> 00:02:15,261
and a greater police presence in our lives.

43
00:02:15,709 --> 00:02:18,974
The creation of PRONASCI 2, the approval
of the Anti-Faction Bill,

44
00:02:18,975 --> 00:02:21,416
and the Security Constitutional
Amendment Proposal

45
00:02:21,516 --> 00:02:25,789
further deepened criminalization
and social militarization.

46
00:02:27,261 --> 00:02:30,237
In the same vein, following the elections,

47
00:02:30,337 --> 00:02:34,280
the slogan “Protection for workers;
prison for criminals”

48
00:02:34,380 --> 00:02:35,763
started to be repeated,

49
00:02:35,863 --> 00:02:39,432
reinforcing the government’s commitment
to expanding incarceration

50
00:02:39,532 --> 00:02:42,013
as a solution to social conflicts.

51
00:02:42,113 --> 00:02:46,803
Although this slogan may sound more
palatable to progressive ears

52
00:02:46,903 --> 00:02:49,907
when compared to “a good criminal
is a dead criminal,”

53
00:02:50,419 --> 00:02:53,139
it is worth remembering that,
just like the police,

54
00:02:53,239 --> 00:02:55,912
prisons are also killing machines.

55
00:02:56,012 --> 00:02:57,672
In 2025 alone,

56
00:02:57,772 --> 00:03:01,640
3,318 people died inside
the prison system.

57
00:03:02,740 --> 00:03:05,427
More than 40 years of mass incarceration,

58
00:03:05,527 --> 00:03:08,371
under the guise of a “war on
drugs and crime,”

59
00:03:08,471 --> 00:03:12,083
has been long enough to show that it
doesn't solve anything.

60
00:03:12,424 --> 00:03:13,384
On the contrary,

61
00:03:13,484 --> 00:03:15,880
there's been an industrialization
of prisons,

62
00:03:15,980 --> 00:03:19,453
followed by the mass production
of incarcerated people

63
00:03:19,553 --> 00:03:21,875
in large prison complexes.

64
00:03:23,144 --> 00:03:26,099
Prisons are increasingly
overcrowded with Black,

65
00:03:26,199 --> 00:03:30,184
Indigenous, poor, feminized,
and trans people.

66
00:03:30,284 --> 00:03:32,979
It was also through the
expansion of prisons

67
00:03:33,079 --> 00:03:36,179
that criminal factions emerged and grew.

68
00:03:41,469 --> 00:03:43,176
In many ways,

69
00:03:43,276 --> 00:03:47,336
this year’s unopposed approval
of the Anti-Faction Bill—

70
00:03:47,436 --> 00:03:50,429
which established the legal framework
for fighting “organized crime”—

71
00:03:50,529 --> 00:03:53,277
and the Public Security Constitutional
Amendment Proposal

72
00:03:53,377 --> 00:03:56,733
 also signal the Lula administration’s
adaptation to “bukelization”.

73
00:03:57,277 --> 00:04:00,090
In contrast to the proposal to
designate criminal gangs

74
00:04:00,091 --> 00:04:02,141
as narco-terrorist organizations,

75
00:04:02,241 --> 00:04:07,507
the Anti-Faction Law created two new criminal
offenses that are equally vague:

76
00:04:07,607 --> 00:04:10,056
the crimes of “structured social domination”

77
00:04:10,156 --> 00:04:13,373
and “aiding and abetting structured
social domination.”

78
00:04:13,473 --> 00:04:16,989
This further expands the
racialized criminalization

79
00:04:17,089 --> 00:04:18,856
of marginalized territories.

80
00:04:19,496 --> 00:04:21,254
After just six months in effect,

81
00:04:21,354 --> 00:04:23,765
the Anti-Faction Law has led
to the criminalization

82
00:04:23,766 --> 00:04:25,928
of funk musicians for glorifying crime,

83
00:04:26,028 --> 00:04:28,819
the arrest of people distributing food,

84
00:04:28,919 --> 00:04:32,765
and the detention of teenagers accused
of belonging to gangs.

85
00:04:32,909 --> 00:04:36,029
The Security Constitutional Amendment
Proposal, in turn,

86
00:04:36,129 --> 00:04:37,428
is a far-right initiative,

87
00:04:37,528 --> 00:04:40,509
currently being advanced with the
support of Lula's administration

88
00:04:40,609 --> 00:04:45,011
and justified as a reinforcement of
the Unified Public Security System.

89
00:04:45,608 --> 00:04:49,896
Its approval was widely celebrated
among the progressive left,

90
00:04:50,280 --> 00:04:52,883
which indicates just how effective
the the far right has been

91
00:04:52,983 --> 00:04:56,413
in dictating the direction of
public security.

92
00:04:57,309 --> 00:04:58,419
In summary,

93
00:04:58,519 --> 00:05:00,488
the process of “Bukelization,”

94
00:05:00,588 --> 00:05:02,803
embodied by these new laws,

95
00:05:02,903 --> 00:05:07,091
manifests itself in the harshening and
lengthening of sentences;

96
00:05:07,191 --> 00:05:11,464
in the restriction of rights for people
imprisoned waiting final conviction,

97
00:05:11,564 --> 00:05:13,622
such as the revocation
of the right to vote;

98
00:05:13,623 --> 00:05:15,817
the restriction of benefits to
families of prisoners

99
00:05:15,817 --> 00:05:19,064
and of the progression to a less restrictive
regime for those accused

100
00:05:19,065 --> 00:05:20,754
of belonging to criminal factions;

101
00:05:20,855 --> 00:05:25,416
and the expansion of maximum-security
prisons, among other measures.

102
00:05:25,853 --> 00:05:28,381
Social movements and organizations

103
00:05:28,481 --> 00:05:32,616
have highlighted the contradiction between
these legislative measures

104
00:05:32,716 --> 00:05:34,643
and the presumption of innocence,

105
00:05:34,743 --> 00:05:37,672
an immutable clause of the
federal constitution.

106
00:05:38,301 --> 00:05:39,965
Added to this process

107
00:05:40,065 --> 00:05:43,837
is Lula’s proposal to convert 138 prisons

108
00:05:43,937 --> 00:05:45,949
into maximum-security facilities.

109
00:05:46,899 --> 00:05:50,099
This does not mean that
there is no distinction

110
00:05:50,199 --> 00:05:53,501
between far-right and progressive governments

111
00:05:53,601 --> 00:05:55,869
when it comes to public safety.

112
00:05:56,147 --> 00:05:58,333
Lula's government has distinguished itself

113
00:05:58,433 --> 00:06:01,395
by relying on science and intelligence

114
00:06:01,495 --> 00:06:02,685
in the “fight against crime”.

115
00:06:02,963 --> 00:06:04,979
As seen in Operation Carbono Oculto

116
00:06:05,079 --> 00:06:07,549
and the creation of the
Território Seguro program,

117
00:06:07,649 --> 00:06:10,173
in partnership with the
University of São Paulo.

118
00:06:10,824 --> 00:06:11,720
However,

119
00:06:11,820 --> 00:06:14,611
the scientific justification
for the use of violence

120
00:06:14,711 --> 00:06:17,352
does not make it any less violent,

121
00:06:17,452 --> 00:06:21,960
nor does it dismantle the structures
responsible for perpetrating violence—

122
00:06:22,060 --> 00:06:25,542
especially against marginalized
bodies and territories

123
00:06:25,543 --> 00:06:27,816
identified as non-white.

124
00:06:28,072 --> 00:06:29,053
On the contrary,

125
00:06:29,153 --> 00:06:30,963
it rationalizes this violence

126
00:06:31,063 --> 00:06:34,611
and justifies its authority.

127
00:06:36,413 --> 00:06:38,163
Over the past four years,

128
00:06:38,263 --> 00:06:41,160
the concept of “integration”
has also become part

129
00:06:41,260 --> 00:06:43,677
of police operations and forces.

130
00:06:44,136 --> 00:06:46,174
The Unified Public Security System,

131
00:06:46,274 --> 00:06:48,637
created during President
Temer’s administration,

132
00:06:48,737 --> 00:06:50,632
seeks to establish an integrated use

133
00:06:50,732 --> 00:06:52,320
of the various security forces

134
00:06:52,420 --> 00:06:54,226
in the fight against organized crime.

135
00:06:54,327 --> 00:06:57,533
        This integration points to a process

136
00:06:57,633 --> 00:06:59,976
of rationalizing police violence

137
00:07:00,076 --> 00:07:02,227
and the infrastructure of the penal state.

138
00:07:02,730 --> 00:07:04,594
This is the case with Operation Impact

139
00:07:04,695 --> 00:07:06,888
and Operations Shield and Summer,

140
00:07:06,988 --> 00:07:09,245
which, in 2023 and 2024,

141
00:07:09,345 --> 00:07:11,677
killed 84 people

142
00:07:11,777 --> 00:07:13,565
and made more than 2,000 arrests.

143
00:07:14,152 --> 00:07:17,405
Operation Impact, carried out in 2023,

144
00:07:17,505 --> 00:07:19,357
consists of a coordinated effort

145
00:07:19,457 --> 00:07:22,237
by the security forces of
the states of São Paulo,

146
00:07:22,337 --> 00:07:24,541
Rio Grande do Sul, Mato Grosso do Sul,

147
00:07:24,641 --> 00:07:25,864
and Santa Catarina.

148
00:07:26,365 --> 00:07:29,149
Another example is Operation
Território Seguro,

149
00:07:29,249 --> 00:07:31,816
carried out in the state
of Rio Grande do Norte.

150
00:07:32,456 --> 00:07:35,891
And these “integrated” operations
by state police forces

151
00:07:35,991 --> 00:07:37,864
have become increasingly common.

152
00:07:38,184 --> 00:07:41,608
With the aim of increasing the
productivity of security forces,

153
00:07:41,708 --> 00:07:44,232
massive numbers of incarcerations—

154
00:07:44,332 --> 00:07:45,512
and even deaths—

155
00:07:45,612 --> 00:07:47,891
have become measures of “efficiency.”

156
00:07:48,595 --> 00:07:49,544
Furthermore,

157
00:07:49,644 --> 00:07:52,467
this process of integrating security forces

158
00:07:52,567 --> 00:07:56,136
has been accompanied by an expansion
of police presence

159
00:07:56,236 --> 00:07:59,336
and the militarization of security forces.

160
00:08:00,548 --> 00:08:04,018
The approval of the Public Security
Constitutional Amendment Proposal

161
00:08:04,119 --> 00:08:07,688
made the creation of municipal
police forces constitutional

162
00:08:07,788 --> 00:08:12,616
and expanded the roles of the
federal highway police,

163
00:08:12,716 --> 00:08:16,221
transforming them into a kind
of federal military police.

164
00:08:18,173 --> 00:08:22,653
These measures will further expand the
political power of the police,

165
00:08:22,753 --> 00:08:25,565
one of the main pillars of the far right,

166
00:08:25,665 --> 00:08:27,869
which actually grew stronger

167
00:08:27,969 --> 00:08:31,528
even during Lula and Dilma Rousseff's
administrations.

168
00:08:36,360 --> 00:08:37,576
In recent years,

169
00:08:37,676 --> 00:08:41,480
movements against mass incarceration
and police violence

170
00:08:41,580 --> 00:08:44,232
seem to have become even more isolated.

171
00:08:44,332 --> 00:08:48,520
Even modest reforms that would help
reduce mass incarceration

172
00:08:48,620 --> 00:08:52,360
and demilitarize the police seem
further out of reach.

173
00:08:52,808 --> 00:08:54,909
And the solutions to social conflicts

174
00:08:55,009 --> 00:08:57,363
presented by the progressive government

175
00:08:57,463 --> 00:08:59,421
consist of expanding prisons

176
00:08:59,521 --> 00:09:01,939
and increasing the police
presence in our lives,

177
00:09:02,039 --> 00:09:05,021
with their “needs” and “authority”

178
00:09:05,121 --> 00:09:08,285
glossed over by a series of
state-sanctioned sciences.

179
00:09:09,437 --> 00:09:12,915
The general climate has grown harsher

180
00:09:13,015 --> 00:09:15,037
for those of us who
insist on dreaming

181
00:09:15,137 --> 00:09:17,261
of a world without prisons
and police.

182
00:09:17,384 --> 00:09:19,326
But when has it ever been any different?

183
00:09:19,635 --> 00:09:21,747
This world has always been
against us.

184
00:09:22,419 --> 00:09:24,488
The radicalization of punitive measures,

185
00:09:24,588 --> 00:09:26,222
under pressure from the far right,

186
00:09:26,322 --> 00:09:28,278
demands a response that is up to the task—

187
00:09:28,279 --> 00:09:31,261
one that involves building
a collective struggle

188
00:09:31,361 --> 00:09:35,304
capable of blocking any attempt to lower
the age of criminal liability

189
00:09:35,404 --> 00:09:37,299
and strengthen the police,

190
00:09:37,725 --> 00:09:39,645
no matter where it comes from.

191
00:09:40,904 --> 00:09:41,843
Furthermore,

192
00:09:41,943 --> 00:09:43,965
the only possible opposition

193
00:09:44,065 --> 00:09:47,048
to the far-right’s public safety agenda

194
00:09:47,148 --> 00:09:49,480
consists ofstepping outside
its playing field,

195
00:09:49,580 --> 00:09:53,128
rather than reinforcing
its terms and language.

196
00:09:53,525 --> 00:09:56,210
Blocking the lowering of the age
of criminal liability,

197
00:09:56,311 --> 00:09:58,184
may be a first step

198
00:09:58,284 --> 00:10:01,533
toward mounting an offensive
against the Penal State.

199
00:10:02,417 --> 00:10:06,034
Those in the House of Representatives
and the Senate are conspiring

200
00:10:06,135 --> 00:10:08,819
to sacrifice the lives of Black, Indigenous,

201
00:10:08,919 --> 00:10:11,507
poor, and dissident youth

202
00:10:11,607 --> 00:10:14,141
on the altar of a democracy in crisis,

203
00:10:14,241 --> 00:10:18,877
all to save this system and its institutions.

204
00:10:19,368 --> 00:10:20,712
In response,

205
00:10:20,812 --> 00:10:24,392
we must sacrifice this system of death

206
00:10:24,492 --> 00:10:25,757
in the name of life,

207
00:10:25,857 --> 00:10:29,043
thwarting their plans to solve the crisis

208
00:10:29,143 --> 00:10:32,296
with a cup overflowing with
prisons and blood.

